Best MLB Betting Sites in New Jersey

Sports betting is a big deal in the US. In the country, NJ is a popular state for gambling fans, especially those who like MLB baseball betting. If you’re also interested in wagering on baseball games in New Jersey, we’ve got the best sportsbooks for you in this guide. All the sites listed here are fully tested and vetted by our experts. Visit any one of them and start placing your wagers on your favorite matchups.
Written by
Jeffrey Scott
Updated
Apr 24, 2024

Top Recommended Sportsbooks for MLB Betting in New Jersey

Safe and licenced
Safe and licenced
Top rated
Top rated
Faster payments
Faster payments
High payments
High payments
#
Rating
Bonus
Features
Play
1
Rating
5 /5
Read review
Get $25 Free Bonus
100% Up to 1000$ Welcome Bonus
T&C apply

DESCRIPTION OF PROMOTION

  • Welcome Offer for new BetMGM Casino accounts; includes a $25 Casino Bonus and a 100% Deposit Match, up to $1,000.

ELIGIBILITY

  • New BetMGM Casino accounts only (no prior accounts, wagering or deposits).
  • To be eligible, players must be 21 years of age or older and playing within the state of New Jersey.
  • All personal and contact data associated with the player’s account must be verifiable.

ACTION REQUIRED

  • BetMGM Casino may modify the rules at any time by posting the modified terms on the relevant page(s) of the platform. We recommend you revisit the Standard Promotional Terms regularly. By your continued participation in the promotion, you accept any such modified terms.
  • Please review the Standard Promotional Terms by signing in to your BetMGM Casino account> General Terms & Conditions> Legal Matters> Standard Promotional Terms & Conditions.

CLAIMING PROMOTIONAL OFFER

  • $25 Casino Bonus
    • $25 Casino Bonus will be available for three (3) days after completion of new account registration.
    • $25 Casino Bonus received from this promotion is available at BetMGM Casino only and cannot be used on Jackpot Slots, poker, or sports.
  • $1,000 Deposit Match
    • The minimum required first deposit is $10.
    • Deposit Match will equal first deposit, up to $1,000 in Casino Bonus maximum.
    • Deposit Match offer expires thirty (30) days after completing new account registration at BetMGM Casino.
    • Deposit Match Casino Bonus received from this promotion is available at BetMGM Casino only and cannot be used on poker or sports.
  • All available bonus offers can be found in the Casino Promotions tab after signing in.

LIMITATIONS ON PARTICIPATION

  • Only one (1) offer per household is eligible for this offer, as identified by information submitted upon signup.
  • Players may only participate in one (1) Welcome Offer promotion; by participating in this promotion, a player is ineligible to participate in similar promotions offered by our sports or poker brands.
  • Players will earn BetMGM Rewards Points on all cash and Casino Bonus wagering.

WAGERING REQUIREMENTS

  • $25 Casino Bonus
    • The wagering requirement is 1x the Casino Bonus amount. For every $1 in Casino Bonus, the player must wager $1. For example: if a player receives a $5 Casino Bonus, the player must wager $5 to cash out the bonus and any associated winnings.
    • Casino Bonus wagering requirement must be completed within seven (7) days.
    • Players can opt in to multiple bonuses at any given time. However, they can only contribute to the Casino Bonus wagering requirements for one (1) bonus at a time. The Casino Bonus wagering requirement applies to the first activated bonus unless the player pauses said bonus and resumes play on another bonus in the Bonus tab. Players can pause and resume bonuses multiple times until they expire.
    • Players can opt out of a bonus at any time.
    • Should players opt out of this bonus or the bonus expires prior to completing the wagering requirement, the Casino Bonus and winnings derived from the Casino Bonus will be removed from the player’s account.
    • All BetMGM Casino game play contributes toward the $25 Casino Bonus wagering requirement.
  • $1,000 Deposit Match
    • The wagering requirement is 15x the Casino Bonus amount. For every $1 in Casino Bonus, the player must wager $15. For example: if a player receives a $5 Casino Bonus, the player must wager $75 to cash out the bonus and any associated winnings.
    • Players have fourteen (14) days following the qualifying deposit to complete the Casino Bonus wagering requirement. The earn-out period expires at 11:59 pm on the fourteenth day following the qualifying deposit.
    • Players can opt in to multiple bonuses at any given time. However, they can only contribute to the Casino Bonus wagering requirements for one (1) bonus at a time. The Casino Bonus wagering requirement applies to the first activated bonus unless the player pauses said bonus and resumes play on another bonus in the Bonus tab. Players can pause and resume using bonuses multiple times until they expire.
    • Players can opt out of a bonus at any time.
    • Should the player opt out of this bonus or the bonus expires prior to completing the wagering requirement, the Casino Bonus and winnings derived from the Casino Bonus will be removed from the player’s account.
    • All BetMGM Casino game play contributes toward the Deposit Match Casino Bonus wagering requirement.
  • GAME CONTRIBUTIONS TOWARD BONUS WAGERING
    • The percentage of your wager that counts toward your wagering requirement varies based on the game you are playing. Here are the percentages:
      • Slots, Jackpot Slots, Scratch Cards, Fixed Odds Games, Virtual Games: 100%
        • For Example: If I play $125 on Scratch Games → I release it, as they count 100%.
      • Table Games, Roulette, Live Dealer (all games), Video Poker, Baccarat, Craps: 20%
        • For Example: If I play $125 on Roulette → Only $25 is counted, as Roulette counts 20%.
      • Blackjack (non-Live Dealer only): 10%
        • For Example: If I play $125 on Blackjack → Only $12.50 is counted, as Blackjack counts 10%.

ORDER OF FUNDS USED FOR WAGERING

  • After the player’s account is credited with a bonus and the player starts a new game session, the bonus will be used first to complete the wagering requirement. Upon completion of the wagering requirement, any winnings will be credited to the player’s cash balance, and any subsequent wagers will be debited from the cash balance.
  • For the Deposit Match bonus, deposit amount + bonus amount + any winnings are restricted until the wagering requirement is completed. The restricted amount is wagered first, followed by the available balance.

ELIGIBLE GAMES

  • All BetMGM Casino games (Jackpot Slots excluded where noted).

WITHDRAWAL RESTRICTIONS

  • $25 Casino Bonus
    • Any winnings received from the $25 Casino Bonus are not eligible for withdrawal unless the player has made a deposit and met the wagering requirement. In this case, any winnings will then be eligible for withdrawal if requested.
    • To cash out Casino Bonus and associated winnings, players must complete the wagering requirement.
  • $1,000 Deposit Match
    • To cash out the Casino Bonus and associated winnings, players must complete the wagering requirement.
    • In order to cash out the remaining deposit amount prior to completing the wagering requirement, the player must first drop out of the promotion.
      • By dropping the bonus from this promotion, any Casino Bonus received as a result of the Deposit Match bonus will be forfeited. This includes the full amount of the initial Casino Bonus and any associated winnings.
      • For example, scenario 1: Player deposits $1,000 resulting in a $1,000 Casino Bonus awarded as a Deposit Match bonus. The player then plays on slots and loses $500 after which the player decides to drop this bonus. As a result, the player’s remaining available deposit will be $500 as they forfeit the full Casino Bonus of $1,000 by dropping out of the promotion.
      • Scenario 2: Player deposits $1,000 resulting in a $1,000 Casino Bonus awarded as a Deposit Match bonus. The player then plays on slots and wins $500 after which the player decides to drop this bonus. As a result, the player’s remaining available deposit will be $1,000 as they will forfeit the full Casino Bonus of $1,000 and the $500 winnings associated with it.

CANCELLATION

  • Upon request for cancellation, BetMGM Casino will inform the player of the amount of unrestricted funds that will be returned upon cancellation and the value of restricted funds that will be removed from the player’s online gaming account. If the player elects to proceed with cancellation, unrestricted funds remaining in a player’s online gaming account will be returned in accordance with the Terms and Conditions.
  • BetMGM Casino reserves the right to alter, discontinue or terminate any promotion, or any aspect of it, at any time, with or without notice, for any reason whatsoever, including without limitation if there has been any printing, production, distribution or other error in any promotion communication or on the platform, or where there has been any error in the preparation for or conduct of any promotion affecting the result of the promotion or the number of participants or the value of claims.
  • BetMGM Casino reserves the right to change or cancel this promotion in its entirety, or exclude any individual or individuals from participation, if it determines at its sole discretion that there are any irregularities or abuses occurring in connection with the promotion.
  • General Terms and Conditions apply.
  • OLG Internal Control Trigger Based applies to this promotion.

Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Must be 21+. NJ only. Please Gamble Responsibly. Visit BetMGM.com for Terms and Conditions. All promotions are subject to qualification and eligibility requirements. Rewards issued as non-withdrawable site credit/Bonus Bets unless otherwise provided in the applicable terms. Rewards subject to expiry.

  • No Max Cashout No Playthrough Bonus
  • Total Casino Sign-up Bonus: Up to $1,025
  • Quick payouts normally approved within 24 hours
Read review
  • Refer a friend bonus
  • MGM Rewards Program
  • Slots from IGT, NetEnt, Red Tiger, WMS
Established
2017
Licence
NJ
Total Games
200+
  • Visa
  • Mastercard
  • American Express
  • PayPal
  • Apple Pay
  • Discover
  • Online Banking Transfer
  • Pay Near Me
  • Play+
  • Venmo
2
Rating
4.9 /5
Read review
Get up to $1,000 Risk-Free Bonus
+ $100 in site credits
T&C apply

Join Casino and deposit $10 to get 50 Bonus Spins! Plus, get up to $1000 back in Casino Bonus if you’re down after your first day!

How it works:

  • Join FanDuel Casino

  • Deposit $10+

  • 50 Bonus Spins will be added to your account

    • Play your Bonus Spins on any eligible slot games

    • Eligible slot games: Cash Eruption, Cleopatra, and Declaration of Spindependence

    • 1X Play Through on all Bonus Spins

    • Just play through your spins once and any winnings are yours to keep

  • Get up to $1000 back in Casino Bonus if you’re down after your first day!

    • Bonus period begins when you make your first real money wager and extends for 24 hours

    • Receive a refund in non-withdrawable Casino Bonus for your net losses in your first 24 hours of Casino play. Maximum Bonus $1,000.

    • Casino Bonus will be automatically applied to your account within 72 hours of the end of the bonus period.

    • Bonus expires 7 days after receipt.

More details:

  • Bonus funds ineligible
  • Users who placed bets with FanDuel Sportsbook are not eligible for this offer.
  • Get up to $1000 back
  • Cashback on Blackjack
  • Built on GAN’s GameStack platform
Read review
  • Venmo and PayPal banking
  • 5* rated mobile app
  • 24/7 live chat
Established
2018
Licence
NJ
Total Games
400+
  • Visa
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • ACH
  • Venmo
3
Rating
4.9 /5
Read review
100% Up to $500
$10 Sign Up Bonus
T&C apply

Make your First Deposit and use 

Bonus Code CASINOBACK to receive 

100% of Net Losses back on the first

24 hours of play, up to $500!

At BetRivers Online Casino, we’re welcoming you with the best incentives.

We have a 1X play through requirement- that means that after you activate your bonus,

you wager through 1X, and any winnings are converted to cash!

PLAY NOW to receive 100% of net losses back up to $500 on the first 24 hours, when you play qualifying Casino games!

*First time depositors only.

  • Promo code:
  • Deposit Code: CASINO500
  • Access to 250 top-tier games
  • Excellent loyalty program
Read review
  • User-friendly BetRivers app
  • Wide range of payment methods
Established
2016
Licence
NJ
Total Games
250+
  • Visa
  • Mastercard
  • ACH
  • Cash at Casino Cage
  • Online Banking Transfer
  • Pay Near Me
  • Play+
4
Rating
4.8 /5
Read review
Get $20 No Deposit Bonus
Up to $500 Welcome Bonus
T&C apply

$20 Free Registration offer short T&C’s:

  • New players only
  • One-time offer valid from 2/26/20 and until further notice
  • Bonus is only valid if claimed by communication within 48 hours
  • Bonus must be wagered 30 times within 60 days from granting
  • Wagering contributions apply and vary by game
  • Bonus is valid for Casino games only
  • Withdrawal restrictions and full terms & conditions apply

Up to $500 Welcome Bonus short T&C’s:

  • First deposit only of $20 minimum
  • One time offer
  • Valid from 5/4/20 and until further notice
  • Bonus must be wagered 30 times within 60 days from granting
  • Wagering contributions apply and vary by game
  • Bonus is valid for Casino games only
  • Withdrawal restrictions and full terms & conditions apply
  • No Max Cashout Sign Up Bonus
  • More than 650 online slot titles
  • 18 languages available
Read review
  • 24/7 Customer Support and Online Chat service
  • IOS and Android apps
Established
1997
Licence
NJ
Total Games
2000+
  • Visa
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • ACH
  • Discover
  • Online Banking Transfer
  • Pay Near Me
  • Play+

Baseball betting online must be done on a reputable website. The following list of sports betting sites in New Jersey has the greatest platforms in the region. They all offer a complete gambling experience, with generous bonuses and reliable support.

Mastering MLB Odds and Bets in New Jersey

Like with other online sports betting, baseball also requires you to understand how odds and bets work. This information will help you place more informed wagers in NJ before you join baseball betting sites.

How MLB Odds Work

MLB Odds and Bets in New Jersey
MLB Odds and Bets in New Jersey

Odds in this sport work similarly to the NFL and NBA. There are many to choose from. They tell you what the chances of each bet being successful are. Online baseball betting relies on reading these numbers, assessing the possible outcomes, and placing your wager.

Diving Deep into MLB Betting Options

Here are common MLB online betting odds you’ll see in NJ.

Run Line vs. Moneyline

Run Line bets handicap the favorite team to win while giving the underdog an advantage. For example, if Team A’s the favorite and there’s a Run Line of 1.5, it must win by at least 2 runs for the bet to succeed. Conversely, the underdog Team B must either win the game or lose by 1 run for the bet to come through.

Moneyline bets also revolve around favorites and underdogs but are designed differently. The basic principle is that a positive moneyline wager tells you how much you’ll win for a $100 bet, while the negative one tells you the amount you need to bet to win $100.

Series Betting vs. Individual Game Bets

Series betting relates to placing wagers on who will win an entire tournament, like the National League. This may be highly lucrative but is also very risky. On the other hand, individual game bets are limited to each match. These give you more control over your wagers and are less risky. You must decide which direction you’d like to take, as both have pros and cons.

Prop Bets: What You Need to Know

Baseball betting sites in NJ have prop bet options, too. These are perfect for people who want to stay aware of the stats and updated news to bet on individual events. For example, you may predict the score of a certain player or how many home runs they’ll score. Prop bets don’t have anything to do with the outcome of a game, so there’s less pressure.

MLB Futures: Anticipating the Season

If you’re good with predictions and stats, check out MLB futures odds. A futures bet is made on an event that’ll happen later in the year. This may be on anything like who will win the season or which player will get a specific end-of-season award.

Betting on MLB from New Jersey: The How-To

BETMGM official partner of MLB
BETMGM official partner of the MLB

If you’re unsure about the process, here are the basics to start your MLB betting career. Let’s look at them:

Legality of MLB Betting in NJ

NJ legalized online gambling in 2013. Many betting apps and online sportsbooks have been launched over the years. Such platforms need to get a license from the New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement and get affiliated with a land-based casino.

Using MLB Betting Apps in NJ: A Step-by-Step Guide

Getting started is very easy; just follow these steps:

  1. Step 1 Find a reputable NJ site you wish to join.
  2. Step 2 Create an account by providing some basic information. Some sites require certain documents to be uploaded.
  3. Step 3 Claim your welcome bonus to gain additional funds to bet with.
  4. Step 4 Browse the available odds and place your wager.
  5. Step 5 Upon winning, initiate a withdrawal to your preferred banking method and enjoy!

Geolocation and MLB Betting: What You Need to Know

A part of legalizing sports gambling is individual state laws. Not every region of the country has the same rules and regulations. So, it’s essential to ensure that each player who’s gambling at New Jersey Operators is physically located there. This is where geolocation matters. If it’s detected that a person isn’t in the state they’re gambling in, they aren’t allowed to place any wagers.

Elevating Your MLB Betting Game – Tips and Strategies

To make the most of your cash, follow these strategies to bet on games, and you won’t be disappointed.

Understanding Umpires

Every umpire in the tournament is different. Some fall prey to home pressure, while others prefer road teams. Some consider the strike zone to be tighter than others, while some remain very neutral about everything. Knowing who is umpiring might significantly affect how a game is played out.

Analyzing Pitchers

When carefully analyzing a pitcher, you’ll be better positioned to determine the performance. This is crucial in prop bets. For example, you may correctly predict the number of strikeouts a pitcher will achieve. So, keep a close eye on your favorite pitcher’s performance throughout the season.

Recognizing and Utilizing Streaks

Teams often undergo winning or losing streaks in baseball. Realizing this would help you win more money over time. This isn’t too profitable, as predicting who’ll win if a side has been winning for weeks is easier.

Live Betting: Making Decisions on the Fly

Watching a game live and placing real-time wagers on MLB betting sites is incredible. This way, you’re always up-to-date on the action and able to make more informed decisions while enjoying the game simultaneously.

MLB Games Streaming: Where to Watch

MLB Games Streaming: Where to Watch
MLB Games Streaming: Where to Watch

To engage in live betting, you need to stream games. Of course, you may always watch it on TV. But if you don’t have cable, here are some options for streaming baseball matches:

  • Hulu
  • Peacock
  • YouTube TV
  • Fubo
  • Sling
  • DirecTV Stream

Spotlight on New Jersey’s MLB Affinity

Baseball’s roots are traced back to Hoboken in New Jersey. Nearly two centuries ago, Alexander Cartwright created the Knickerbocker Baseball Club and finalized many of the game’s rules that exist today. Since then, NJ has been the heart and soul of baseball, even though many wouldn’t realize it.

Upcoming MLB Events in NJ

Upcoming MLB Events in NJ
Upcoming MLB Events in NJ

Some of the upcoming baseball events you might want to bet on include the Wild Card Series starting in October, the Division Series from October 7th to 14th, the League Championship from 15th to 24th October, and various World Tours starting early next year.

Physical Sportsbook Locations in New Jersey

If you want to bet at physical locations, these are our top 3 choices.

  • Monmouth Park Sports Book by Caesars

    The Caesars Sportsbook at Monmouth Park is the place to be for all things gambling. It’s open the whole week from early morning to late at night. Like its online version, this physical location also has a bonus for new customers who can place a risk-free wager.

  • Borgata Race & Sports Book / BetMGM Sportsbook & Bar

    The BetMGM Sportsbook & Bar at Borgata spans 8,000 square feet and has a massive LED video wall to show the action. Access one of the six betting windows and place your wagers in the middle of the action.

  • FanDuel Sportsbook at Meadowlands Racetrack

    Touted as the #1 sportsbook in the USA, FanDuel boasts huge screens to view the games along with self-service terminals where placing wagers is quick and easy.

Frequently Asked Questions about MLB Betting in NJ

How does MLB betting differ from other sports?

Baseball differs from basketball and football because there’s no clock. The overall sport is slower and more strategy-based due to this reason.

Are there any special promotions for MLB betting in NJ?

Baseball betting sites in NJ have a plethora of promotions to claim. They range from giving out free bets to refunding failed wagers.

Can I bet on MLB games that are happening outside NJ?

Yes, it’s possible to gamble on baseball events outside the state, as long as you’re present within NJ.